Sunday, November 22, 2026
Court Helicopter
  • Home
  • News
  • Court Update
  • County
  • Explainer
  • Photo-Story
  • Interviews
  • International
  • Africa
  • News Feature
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Court Update
  • County
  • Explainer
  • Photo-Story
  • Interviews
  • International
  • Africa
  • News Feature
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Court Helicopter
Home News

High Court Upholds Sh980,000 Costs Award Against KRA in Doshi Iron Mongers Case

Justice Jairus Ngaah rejected KRA’s challenge to the taxation, ruling that the Sh6.98 million judgment against the authority was the proper basis for calculating instruction fees.

CH Reporter by CH Reporter
October 4, 2026
in News
0
Court Upholds Sh765,000 Award to Sacked Employee, Faults Company for Firing Him Without Hearing

Four people have been sentenced over the April 2024 murder of Richard Chumba and Patrick Komen in Baringo County, following a violent confrontation over disputed land.

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsApp

The High Court in Mombasa dismissed a petition by the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) against a Sh979,987 costs award in favour of Doshi Iron Mongers Limited, bringing a closure to a long-running legal dispute over the seizure and detention of the company’s goods.

Justice Jairus Ngaah, in a ruling delivered on September 25, 2026, upheld the decision of a taxing officer who had assessed Doshi Iron Mongers’ party-and-party bill of costs at Sh979,987.

Related posts

Sonko Links Uhuru Fallout to Budget Row, Claims Sh2M Paid to Senators for His Impeachment

Nyeri Man Sentenced to 50 Years in Prison for Murder of Eight-Year-Old Stepson

November 22, 2026
The Kenya Magistrates and Judges Association Treasurer Faults Judiciary’s Ranking of Judges, Says Performance Data Is Illogical

The Kenya Magistrates and Judges Association Treasurer Faults Judiciary’s Ranking of Judges, Says Performance Data Is Illogical

November 22, 2026

KRA had asked the court to overturn the taxation decision made by Deputy Registrar Noelyne Reuben on January 24, 2025, arguing that several items had been wrongly assessed and that the resulting award was excessive. The authority also sought, in the alternative, to have the disputed items taxed afresh by another taxing officer.

The dispute traces its origins to a 2019 High Court judgment in which Doshi Iron Mongers succeeded in its suit arising from the seizure and detention of its goods. KRA subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal. In February 2024, the appellate court partly allowed the appeal, reducing the special damages awarded against KRA from Sh7.126 million to Sh6.682 million. The Sh300,000 general damages award against the authority remained intact. The total award against KRA therefore stood at approximately Sh6.982 million.

It was on the basis of that judgment that Doshi Iron Mongers filed its party-and-party bill of costs for taxation. The taxing officer subsequently allowed Sh239,649 as instruction fees and Sh79,883.11 as getting-up fees, while allowing the remaining items as drawn. The total bill came to Sh979,987.

One of KRA’s main arguments was that the instruction fee had been calculated using the value of the judgment when, in its view, the dispute concerned the seizure of goods and should have attracted a lower, reasonable or flat fee. The authority proposed an instruction fee of Sh55,000 and a getting-up fee of Sh18,333.

The judge held that the case was an ordinary civil suit for damages which had proceeded to judgment and resulted in a quantified monetary award. It was therefore different from judicial review proceedings, where the court is primarily concerned with the legality of a decision-making process rather than awarding a specific sum of money.

The judge said the applicable rules required the instruction fee in such a case to be calculated by reference to the value of the subject matter where that value could be ascertained. Since the Court of Appeal had ultimately determined the award against KRA at Sh6,982,467, that figure was properly used as the basis for calculating the instruction fee. “Where judgment has been entered, it is the judgment, not the pleadings, that fixes the value of the subject matter,” the judge held. He consequently found no error in the taxing officer’s assessment of the Sh239,649 instruction fee.

KRA had also relied on the scale applicable to appeals, arguing that the instruction fee should have been assessed under that provision.

The High Court rejected that position, noting that the bill being taxed arose from the original High Court proceedings and not from an appeal. Justice Ngaah observed that the underlying case was neither an appeal nor a judicial review application. It was a substantive civil claim. The judge also rejected KRA’s reliance on a separate Court of Appeal decision involving judicial review proceedings, holding that the circumstances of that case were materially different.

KRA further challenged numerous items relating to the service of court documents, arguing that the amounts were substantial, unsupported by receipts and lacked evidence of physical service. The disputed service items amounted to a claim by KRA for a reduction of approximately Sh519,600.

The court, however, found that the charges had been calculated under the mileage scale contained in the Advocates (Remuneration) Order. The documents had been served in Nairobi from Mombasa, a distance of more than 450 kilometres. The judge noted that KRA did not dispute that service had occurred in Nairobi. Justice Ngaah held that mileage charges under the prescribed scale were not ordinary out-of-pocket disbursements requiring receipts in the same manner as expenses supported by specific purchases.

According to KRA, the bill ran from item 1 to 122 before again numbering items from 113 to 144. The authority argued that the irregular numbering could have resulted in duplication and contributed to an inflated award.

The judge found that the numbering error, by itself, did not establish that any item had actually been charged twice. He said KRA, needed to identify the specific item or items allegedly duplicated and demonstrate that the final figure included the same amount more than once. The court therefore treated the numbering problem as a clerical irregularity that had not been shown to cause prejudice or affect the amount awarded.

Justice Ngaah stressed that a reference is not an ordinary appeal and does not give a judge an opportunity simply to substitute his or her own assessment of costs for that of the taxing officer.

The court will ordinarily interfere only where the taxing officer has committed an error of principle or where the amount awarded is so manifestly excessive that it supports an inference of such an error. The court also noted that taxation seeks to strike a balance between fairly compensating a successful litigant and ensuring that costs do not become so high as to restrict access to justice.

The court upheld the taxing officer’s January 24, 2025 decision and the certificate of taxation awarding Doshi Iron Mongers Sh979,987.

The ruling leaves intact the costs award arising from a dispute that began with the seizure and detention of Doshi Iron Mongers’ goods and has traversed both the High Court and Court of Appeal. The decision also provides a reminder that, once a civil claim has resulted in a quantified judgment, that adjudged amount will ordinarily form the basis for determining instruction fees where the applicable remuneration rules so provide.

Previous Post

Court Puts Supervisors on Notice Over Staff Errors After Sh48m Banking Loss

Next Post

High Court Upholds Life Sentence for Kakamega Man Convicted of Defilement

CH Reporter

CH Reporter

Next Post
Judge Rules Consensual teen Relationships Should Not Be Treated as sexual offenses

High Court Upholds Life Sentence for Kakamega Man Convicted of Defilement

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • Africa
  • County
  • Court Update
  • Explainer
  • International
  • Interviews
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Photo-Story
  • World News

BROWSE BY TOPICS

#Safaricom #Sakaja Africa Creative Feature Human Rights IPOA Legal Today Maandamano Mathare News Populer sepulchral rights trend Video

POPULAR

Two KRA Officials Acquitted of Sh1 Million Theft and Abuse of Office in Sh3.9 Billion Fraud Case
News

Two KRA Officials Acquitted of Sh1 Million Theft and Abuse of Office in Sh3.9 Billion Fraud Case

by CH Reporter
November 18, 2026
0

A Milimani court has acquitted two Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) officials who had been placed on their defence over allegations...

End Of Road To a Suspect In Sh7.1 Million Herbicide Fraud as Court Denies Him Bail

End Of Road To a Suspect In Sh7.1 Million Herbicide Fraud as Court Denies Him Bail

November 17, 2026
Former Actress Regina Re’s Daughter Charged with Murder of 86-Year-Old Grandmother

Former Actress Regina Re’s Daughter Charged with Murder of 86-Year-Old Grandmother

November 18, 2026

Lawyer Danstan Omari Demands Sh40 Million From Duke Ombagi Over Alleged Defamatory Remarks and Threats

November 16, 2026
Petitioner Moves to Block Implementation of Linda Mwananchi Movement Conference Resolution

Petitioner Moves to Block Implementation of Linda Mwananchi Movement Conference Resolution

November 16, 2026
Prof Migai Akech Asks to Assist Court in Gachagua Impeachment Appeal, Challenges Legality of Impeachment

Prof Migai Akech Asks to Assist Court in Gachagua Impeachment Appeal, Challenges Legality of Impeachment

November 16, 2026
Family Wants State to Explain Whereabouts of Missing Kin After Disappearance in ATPU Custody

Family Wants State to Explain Whereabouts of Missing Kin After Disappearance in ATPU Custody

November 17, 2026
Regina Re’s Daughter to Face Murder Charges Over 86-Year-Old Grandmother’s Killing

Regina Re’s Daughter to Face Murder Charges Over 86-Year-Old Grandmother’s Killing

November 17, 2026
Court of Appeal Frees Man Sentenced to Death After Finding Gaps in Robbery Evidence

Court of Appeal Frees Man Sentenced to Death After Finding Gaps in Robbery Evidence

November 18, 2026
Court Helicopter

Court and legal stories from around the country

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • Nyeri Man Sentenced to 50 Years in Prison for Murder of Eight-Year-Old Stepson
  • The Kenya Magistrates and Judges Association Treasurer Faults Judiciary’s Ranking of Judges, Says Performance Data Is Illogical
  • Senator Ole Kina Faces Legal Questions After Threatening to Shoot Auctioneers Over Debt

Category

  • Africa
  • County
  • Court Update
  • Explainer
  • International
  • Interviews
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Photo-Story
  • World News

Recent News

Sonko Links Uhuru Fallout to Budget Row, Claims Sh2M Paid to Senators for His Impeachment

Nyeri Man Sentenced to 50 Years in Prison for Murder of Eight-Year-Old Stepson

November 22, 2026
The Kenya Magistrates and Judges Association Treasurer Faults Judiciary’s Ranking of Judges, Says Performance Data Is Illogical

The Kenya Magistrates and Judges Association Treasurer Faults Judiciary’s Ranking of Judges, Says Performance Data Is Illogical

November 22, 2026

© 2026 Court Helicopter. All rights reserved.

imunify-bot-check
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Court Update
  • County
  • Explainer
  • Photo-Story
  • Interviews
  • International
  • Africa
  • News Feature
  • Opinion

© 2026 Court Helicopter. All rights reserved.