The Ministry of Education has suffered a legal setback after the High Court declared unconstitutional its decision to merge Early Childhood Development Education (ECDE) and primary school teacher training into one diploma programme.
In a judgment delivered on Thursday, November 19, 2026, Justice Patricia Nyaundi ruled that the ministry’s decision to combine the Diploma in Early Childhood Teacher Education (DECTE) and the Diploma in Primary Teacher Education (DPTE) was unlawful for failure to comply with the constitutional requirement for public participation.
The two programmes had been consolidated into a single qualification known as the Diploma in Teacher Education – Pre-Primary and Primary (DTE PP & P) through a circular issued on January 19, 2026.
Although the judge acknowledged that the Ministry of Education has the constitutional mandate to formulate policies, she emphasised that such powers must be exercised within the limits set by the Constitution. In particular, Justice Nyaundi pointed to Article 10, which makes public participation one of the national values and principles of governance that must guide the formulation and implementation of public policy.
The ministry had argued that it undertook extensive consultations across the country and engaged relevant stakeholders before introducing the changes.
However, the judge found that the government had failed to provide documentary evidence to support those claims.
“The first respondent (Ministry of Education) asserts that the extensive nationwide consultations were conducted and that relevant stakeholders were engaged,” Justice Nyaundi stated.
She observed that despite making the claim, the ministry had not produced reports or records showing that the alleged consultations took place.
“However, despite those assertions, the first respondent (Ministry of Education) has not placed before the court the reports or records of the consultations referred to in the replying affidavit,” the judge added.
Justice Nyaundi further noted that without such evidence, the court could not establish whether the constitutional requirement had been met.
She held that the ministry’s failure to demonstrate that public participation had taken place left the petitioner’s allegations unchallenged. Consequently, the court declared unconstitutional the circular dated January 19, 2026, issued by the Ministry of Education’s State Department for Basic Education.
“A declaration hereby issues that the circular dated January 19, 2026, reference number QAS/ECDE/7/1B/2/193 issued by the Ministry of Education State Department for the Basic Education Office of the principal secretary is unconstitutional and therefore null and void and of no legal effect,” Justice Nyaundi ruled.
The judge also issued an order of certiorari quashing the circular, effectively stripping it of any legal force. The court, however, declined to award costs, noting that the petition had been filed in the public interest.













