The High Court has discharged orders barring Chief Justice Martha Koome and the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) from publishing individual performance data for judges and judicial officers in the State of the Judiciary and Administration of Justice Report (SOJAR).
Justice David Mburu on Friday, November 20, lifted the conservatory orders he had issued a day earlier, ruling that the orders had been overtaken by events.
The judge made the decision after the matter came before him for directions on an application filed by Nairobi resident Duncun K. Kariuki, who is challenging the planned publication of individual performance reports for judicial officers. In discharging the orders, Justice Mburu stated that the ex-parte conservatory orders issued on November 19 had been overtaken by events.
“Courts do not issue orders in vain,” the judge observed.
Consequently, the court ordered that the conservatory order prohibiting the JSC and the Chief Justice from publishing individual performance data as an addendum, appendix or in any other form in the SOJAR report be discharged. However, the judge certified Kariuki’s application urgent and admitted it for ex-parte hearing in the first instance.
The court further directed that the matter be mentioned on December 1, 2026, to confirm the filing of submissions, as earlier scheduled.
Kariuki had moved to court on November 19 seeking to stop the publication of individual performance data, which was scheduled to be unveiled during the launch of the State of the Judiciary and Administration of Justice Report on November 20. In his application, he argued that the proposed publication lacked an established regulatory or policy framework and that the accuracy and correctness of the data had not been verified.
He further warned that publishing individual scores without proper context could expose judges and judicial officers to public ridicule, doxxing and other forms of cyber harassment. The petitioner also raised concerns that some courts might be excluded from the exercise, potentially creating discrimination and unnecessary divisions within the Judiciary.
However, Kariuki clarified that he was not opposed to the publication of judicial performance data in principle but wanted proper modalities established to guide the exercise and ensure the information could be fairly interpreted.
The petition raises constitutional questions touching on judicial independence, the dignity and welfare of judicial officers, data protection and the respective mandates of the JSC, the Chief Justice and the Chief Registrar of the Judiciary. Among the provisions cited are Articles 160 and 172 of the Constitution and Section 31 of the Data Protection Act.
The JSC and the Chief Justice are the first and second respondents in the petition, alongside the Attorney General, the National Council on the Administration of Justice and other parties.
The matter will return to court on December 1, 2026, for confirmation of the filing of submissions.














